What you need
Etsy
Quick Elements
Monthly cost
Etsy
No monthly fee to open a shop.
Stronger here
Quick Elements
Essentials is $29 a month on a yearly plan, or $39 month to month.
Listing an item
Etsy
$0.20 for each item you list, whether or not it sells. A listing lasts four months.
Quick Elements
No listing fees. Add as many products as you like.
Stronger here
A share of each sale
Etsy
6.5% of the item, shipping and gift wrap, plus 3% + $0.25 for payment processing.
Quick Elements
3.99% + 30 cents per card sale, card processing included, and no other share.
Stronger here
Advertising
Etsy
Offsite Ads take 15% of a sale they bring in, or 12% once a shop passes $10,000 a year, after which it can’t opt out. Never more than $100 an order.
Quick Elements
No one takes a share of your sales for advertising. You run your own newsletters and ads.
Being found
Etsy
Shoppers already on Etsy looking for handmade and vintage.
Stronger here
Quick Elements
Your own site. Buyers come from search, social and your mailing list.
Your shop
Etsy
Your listings inside Etsy, a click away from other sellers.
Quick Elements
Your own website and brand, with a shop styled to match it.
Stronger here